slumdog millionaire

Once in a while something comes up and makes me come back and write. This time it's the British Indian movie Slumdog Millionaire.

I would have to accept that my first impression of the movie was that it's was pretty good and real , and definitely not a feel good. (Tha't what everyone terming it) The movie shows the slums in Mumbai , children getting blinded for money , police beating up the suspects , riots on the streets of Mumbai, prostitution etc. How can such a movie be feel good.

Oh ,then it stuck me. It's feel good for the people in west to see and realize how lucky they are , that the economic upheavals are nothing compared to the life in slumps of Mumbai or India in general. That's when i get convinced that the director didn't make a movie but actually a real life documentary and it should have been named "Poverty and Crime in India" not Slumdog Millionaire. It has not shied away from showing even a small detail that doesn't show India in bad light. I feel sorry to accept that a lot is not untrue. 
Take for instance the scene at TajMahal. I accept that there is a sewer on the back side of Taj , but couldn't the director have at least avoided adding that into the scene of Taj in the backdrop.

Then there is a classic scene in which a American Couple is duped by the kid and all there Car parts are stolen. In a very American way(as projected by Boyle) they hand that boy a  100 $ bill , pronouncing that's what a normal American would do when cheated. Second half is much better and bollywoodish. 

And I would like people in India to take it as a bitter pill and do something. And for those in west , Mubai is not a slum. The slumps in Mumbai are because Mumbai is the economic capital of india, and people from all parts of india come there for better life. There is a limit to which it can catter to these people and the rest are left to a life in slum. 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why is India an undeveloped country?

Image
Continuing from my earlier post I wanted to answer one more question which I strongly feel about. Why is India an undeveloped country even 50 years into Independence? At the time of our independence it was well accepted that for all of our misery,famines and poverty the British rule was responsible. As a consequence we developed a fear for all things foreign ( Xenophobia ). We adopted a policy which aimed at self reliance. Our exports which at the time of independence were 4.5% of world share dropped to .1 % in late 80’s. Gradually the standards of our industry had dropped to below world standards and even if we were to export our products were just not at par with other countries. All this time the government was sitting on its laurels of having made India a self reliant country in agriculture but it had all this time neglected education. This meant that many more generations even after independence will still be illiterate. Another fact in India being undeveloped has been our long he...
Read more

Bangalore...

Image
Bangalore is a name that has acquired global importance. Its the face of India .It has also brought wealth and prosperity to many (but not for those who were ‘ bangalored ’). I was just 7 yrs old when I first visited Bangalore. It was the garden city of India. And now after fifteen years I came back. But this time not as a visitor, but for work. I am working in an IT company (like many) and earning my livelihood here. But it was a big disappointment for me when I saw Bangalore .It has given a heavy price for being the IT center of India. It is perfect example of what other metro cities had been witnessing for so many years. The influx of non natives. Who come here the opportunities that a city life has to offer. The government has failed badly in coping to this pressure. The infrastructure has been badly neglected. My stay at Bangalore has seen many up and downs. One of the nightmares had been finding a good place to live. Being a north India and that too a Punjabi had me searching f...
Read more